CO129-340 - Governor Nathan Acting Governor May - 1907 [4-6] — Page 711

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Aries paid elsewhere in the Colonial service having due regard to the cost of living in Hong Kong, I am not satisfied that the existing rates of pay can be regarded as insufficient. Moreover, since Mr May's despatch was written, it has been decided that sterling salaries shall in future be paid at the rate of 2/- to the dollar, with the result that a considerable addition has been made to the emoluments of all officers in Hong Kong, and in these circumstances I am not prepared to consent to a further increase.

Mr May adduces figures to show that the prospects of officers in Hong Kong compare unfavourably with those of their colleagues in the Straits Settlements. If, however, any such comparison is to be made, it should be not between the service of Hong Kong and that of the Straits Settlements but between the service of Hong Kong and that of the Straits Settlements and the F.M.S taken together. A comparison on that basis shows that the prospects of Hong Kong compare rather favourably than otherwise with those of officers in the Malay Peninsula, but I will not labour the point as I regard any such comparisons as inadmissible.

The services of Hong Kong, the Straits Settlements, and the F.M.S. are not distinct services but branches of one amalgamated service, officers appointed to any one branch being appointed on the clear understanding that they may be transferred to either of the other branches. Therefore, in considering an officer's prospects, it is necessary to look not only to those appointments which are open to him in the place in which he happens to be serving but to the opportunities for promotion afforded by the service of Hong Kong, the Straits Settlements, and the F.M.S as a whole.

I have &c.

Page 704

Edit History

2026-06-04 20:46:18 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Aries paid elsewhere in the Colonial service having due regard to the cost of living in Hong Kong, I am not satisfied that the existing rates of pay can be regarded as insufficient. Moreover, since Mr May's despatch was written, it has been decided that sterling salaries shall in future be paid at the rate of 2/- to the dollar, with the result that a considerable addition has been made to the emoluments of all officers in Hong Kong, and in these circumstances I am not prepared to consent to a further increase. Mr May adduces figures to show that the prospects of officers in Hong Kong compare unfavourably with those of their colleagues in the Straits Settlements. If, however, any such comparison is to be made, it should be not between the service of Hong Kong and that of the Straits Settlements but between the service of Hong Kong and that of the Straits Settlements and the F.M.S taken together. A comparison on that basis shows that the prospects of Hong Kong compare rather favourably than otherwise with those of officers in the Malay Peninsula, but I will not labour the point as I regard any such comparisons as inadmissible. The services of Hong Kong, the Straits Settlements, and the F.M.S. are not distinct services but branches of one amalgamated service, officers appointed to any one branch being appointed on the clear understanding that they may be transferred to either of the other branches. Therefore, in considering an officer's prospects, it is necessary to look not only to those appointments which are open to him in the place in which he happens to be serving but to the opportunities for promotion afforded by the service of Hong Kong, the Straits Settlements, and the F.M.S as a whole. I have &c. Page 704
Baseline (Original)
: aries paid elsewhere in the Colonial service hammy fald i due regard to the cost of living A in Hong Kong, I am not satisfied that the existing rates of pay can be regarded as insufficient. Moreover, since Mr May's desp was written it has been decided that sterling salaries shall in future be paid at the rate of 2/- to the dollar, with the result that a considerable addition has been made to the emoluments of all officers in Hong Kong, and in these circumstances I am not prepared to consent to al further increase. 3 Mr May adduces figures to shew that the prospects of officers in HongKong compare unfavourable with those of their colleagues in the Straits Settlements. If, however, any such comparison is to be made it should be not between the service of HongKong and that of the Sts Setts but between the service of Hong Kong and that of the Straits Setts ad the F.M.S taken together. A comparison on that basis shows that the prospects of Hong Kong/ff/ffthør compare rather favourably } than otherwise with those of officers in the Malay Peninsula but I will not labour the point as I regard any such comparisons as inadmissible. The services of HongKong, + the Sts Setts and the F.M.S. are not dist- inct services but branches of one amalgam- ated service, officers appointed to any one branch being appointed on the clear unde- standing that they may be transferred to either of the other branches. Therefore, in considering an officer's prospects it is necessary to look not only to those appointments which are open to him in the place in which he happens to be serving but to the opportunities for promotion afforded by the service of Hong Kong the Sts Setts and the F.M.S as a whole. I have &c. 704
2026-06-04 20:46:18 · Baseline
View content

:

aries paid elsewhere in the Colonial service

hammy

fald i due regard to the cost of living

A

in Hong Kong, I am not satisfied that the existing rates of pay can be regarded as

insufficient. Moreover, since Mr May's

desp was written it has been decided that

sterling salaries shall in future be paid at the rate of 2/- to the dollar, with the result

that a considerable addition has been made

to the emoluments of all officers in Hong

Kong, and in these circumstances I am not

prepared to consent to al further increase.

3 Mr May adduces figures to shew that the

prospects of officers in HongKong compare

unfavourable with those of their colleagues in the Straits Settlements. If, however, any

such comparison is to be made it should be

not between the service of HongKong and

that of the Sts Setts but between the service of Hong Kong and that of the Straits Setts ad the F.M.S taken together. A comparison on that basis shows that the prospects of Hong Kong/ff/ffthør compare rather favourably

}

than otherwise with those of officers in

the Malay Peninsula but I will not labour

the point as I regard any such comparisons

as inadmissible. The services of HongKong, +

the Sts Setts and the F.M.S. are not dist-

inct services but branches of one amalgam-

ated service, officers appointed to any

one branch being appointed on the clear unde-

standing that they may be transferred to

either of the other branches. Therefore,

in considering an officer's prospects it

is necessary to look not only to those

appointments which are open to him in the

place in which he happens to be serving but to the opportunities for promotion afforded by the service of Hong Kong

the Sts Setts and the F.M.S as a whole.

I have &c.

704

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.